Honda CBR 600RR Forum banner

1 - 17 of 17 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
51 Posts
Sounds like a supersport class. There could be a lot of really good battles in that class. Definitly a good read. I think a class for the 6's is a great idea, seems like a better feeder class than a 250. Is Dorna still gonna have the 125's?
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
796 Posts
Discussion Starter #3
I think they are worried there will be lots of backlash by Aprilia and KTM so yeah it would smart to keep the 125's.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,216 Posts
sooner or later all 2 strokes will be replaced by 4 strokes. im sure eventually u wont even be able to buy a 2 stroke weed eater.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,510 Posts
whoa thats gonna be sweet then...and looks good for 600 class street bikes because it will give some real good data to the manufacturers
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
995 Posts
There was a meeting between FIM officials, Dorna, and the Japanese bosses in Japan last month about talks of 4 strokes 250 and 400... I think 600 4 strokes is a pointless class at MGP since we already have the 800s..
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
591 Posts
I think production 600's would be a mistake on several fronts.

For one, it immediately excludes everyone but the big 4 Japanese manufacturers since they are the only ones that make 600's. Then there's the fact that we already have 600 racing at the national and international level, why would we be adding a 600 class to GP's?

I posted the following from another thread on the same subject (I'm too lazy to type a new response to cover the same points):

If anything, I say make them race 400 or 450 cc singles or twins. That way the Japanese couldn't get away with tossing in miniature version of their current street 600's and they could keep 250 cc 2 strokes in there. The only problem with this is that it will clearly lead to exploding costs if the Japanese come back en masse to do battle.

I actually asked KRSR and the illustrious panel of American GP champions about what engine formula he thought the support classes (125/250) should switch to. He said, "Well, they never listen to me anyway but I think they should be spec classes."

Now on the surface of it everyone would probably disagree and would be really pissed about such a suggestion but when I think about it more I think it makes sense. 250 and 125 are support classes where the ultimate goal is to move up to Moto GP. The classes right now have zero relevance to the street and really its a one horse race for the most part in both classes so you can't even say that there's competition.

So why not just make them spec classes and be done with it. That way you don't end up with the situation we have now where there are plenty of talented riders who just don't have a chance of winning because they are not on top flight machinery. The racing would certainly be better too.

If the Japanese returned to the support classes and started a war there it really wouldn't benefit anybody and would raise costs. Furthermore, you wouldn't want budgets that would have gone to Moto GP to start getting spent in the support classes. The worst case scenario would be if you ended up with what we had in the AMA a few years ago. Manufacturers spread out across the classes so that each could cherry pick championships from privateers (I'm looking at you Kawasaki and Yamaha).

If only they would listen to Kenny...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
995 Posts
Spec classes is just an idea.... GP2 is a spec class race but it always seem that iSport or the other team that wins the championship all the time.. besides... the 125 and 250 is already a quasi spec class... hehehe
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
591 Posts
Spec classes is just an idea.... GP2 is a spec class race but it always seem that iSport or the other team that wins the championship all the time.. besides... the 125 and 250 is already a quasi spec class... hehehe
Yeah really. As much as I'd like to see KTM racing 125's and 250's are really spec Aprilia classes. KTM is going to do WSBK in a year or two anyway.

I think they could just make it spec Aprilia for the 250's and maybe spec KTM for the 125's or vice versa. Maybe open things up for bid every 5 years or something to allow new manufacturers to get in the game if they can prove they can build a reliable, cost-effective package.

But who knows. There are some new 2 stroke technologies on the horizon that will allow them to burn much cleaner, 2-strokes could just make a comeback on their own. Not too far-fetched considering how much cleaner and more efficient diesel technology has become in the last few years.

Either way, I say for the near term future, 2-stroke spec machines. If they wanna go 4-stroke fine, but spec 4-stroke. If they leave the rules open it is going to touch off a technology war.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
995 Posts
Hmmm... let me try to rephrase that...
Even if you have a spec class like the GP2 series, there will always be a team that wins races... like the iSport team in GP2... if spec class is supposed to be the great equalizer then it didn't a achieve its job... so spec class may be good on paper but in actual fact it isn't all that great
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
591 Posts
Hmmm... let me try to rephrase that...
Even if you have a spec class like the GP2 series, there will always be a team that wins races... like the iSport team in GP2... if spec class is supposed to be the great equalizer then it didn't a achieve its job... so spec class may be good on paper but in actual fact it isn't all that great
Well when you have a team that wins in spec racing its usually because they are the best prepared team with the best drivers. It just takes the equipment out of the equation. This way you have a better idea of what difference the human factor is making.

Spec racing does equalize things but a major misconception about it is that it will prevent a team from dominating. It does no such thing, it just means that one team can't dominate because they have a superior machine.
 

·
Overpaid South Pacific Barista overactive ADHD c
Joined
·
27,367 Posts
There was a meeting between FIM officials, Dorna, and the Japanese bosses in Japan last month about talks of 4 strokes 250 and 400... I think 600 4 strokes is a pointless class at MGP since we already have the 800s..
fully ... 250 450 and then the prem class !! thats the ticket!!! then maybe there will be some cool 250s on the road again!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
995 Posts
fully ... 250 450 and then the prem class !! thats the ticket!!! then maybe there will be some cool 250s on the road again!!
Yep, I got this info from the Sepang International Circuit peeps... it was in relation of introducing Speedway racing to Asia...
 

·
Overpaid South Pacific Barista overactive ADHD c
Joined
·
27,367 Posts
First technical draft has been drawn up. :fiddy:
Hopefully this means we will see some awesome technology coming to our 600cc machines, in due time of course.

http://www.motorcyclenews.com/MCN/sport/sportresults/mcn/2007/september/sep10-16/sep1207motogprulesfor600ccmotogpclassdrawnup/
mine does already!! its a honda.. hehehehe

yeah ,i am thinking the 600 SS class will go nuts if they bring this on.. still think 400cc 4s would be cooler and better in the overall way of the world..
 
1 - 17 of 17 Posts
Top