I just heard from the dealer I bought a new bike from last week that Honda just released new dealer pricing on almost everything 2014 and older and that things were significantly cheaper everywhere in the country on most models.
The msrp right now of the 2013 should be $8999 and the 2014 $9499; add at most $300 for freight and setup (which are BS numbers set by the dealer, but give them something), tax, title and license and you should only be about $1k above msrp. I'd say the dealership is slightly high on the 13, way high on the 14 and like Shinfo said depending on condition, the only true way to know the value of a used bike, about right on the 12 if it's stock and clean.
Get a breakdown of the numbers and see where they are getting the OTD prices from. It's good you asked the OTD price, my first question always, but find out how they get there as well.
However, and this is a big however, find out what's all included in those numbers as well. Sometimes dealers will include the first service or an extended warranty; sometimes you get discounts on accessories.
There are not enough differences between the 12 and 13/14 to pick one over the other one other than the looks so get the best "value" for you.
Mike